On the New Star Trek Movie
I have come out of blogger hibernation for one reason. An important reason. A reason so important, in fact, that it has caused me to come out of blogger hibernation...on account of its importance.
The reason is this: In a world already ravaged by the effects of an economic crisis, a faux medical crisis and, let's face it, increasingly crappy music, we have been given yet another problem to deal with: The wilful invalidation of Star Trek history, integrity and canon.
I imagine the problem started something like this:
NewStarTrekMovieWriterGuy: "Oh, crap. I've gotta write a new movie AND allow for an unending series of sequels?"
JJ Abrams: "Yes. Now get started before I Vulcan death grip your ass!"
NewStarTrekMovieWriterGuy: "But...my creative abilities are stifled, nay downright crushed, by all this history that Star Trek has! It's like...it's like somebody built up this largely consistent universe over decades. And it has an ardent fan-base who know and respect this shit. None of those formulaic scripts I learnt at school will work! What do I do, Double J? What do I do?!"
JJ Abrams: "If you don't get this done, I will maroon you on a spooky island with people who manage to gel their hair while being marooned! Just forget about all of that star trek stuff that's out there"
NewStarTrekMovieWriterGuy: "But won't all those fans be angry about it?"
JJ Abrams: "Listen, I've got a franchise to create here. I can't be concerned about a bunch of nerds. Just say it's happening in an "alternative universe" or something - their kind likes that type of thing."
NewStarTrekMovieWriterGuy: "Wow, Double-J! You're a genius! Now I can go wild and just plug star trek names and places, and nothing else into my ActionMovie-O-Matic and write your movie!"
...and that's how the creators of the new Star Trek movie, while making an admitedly good film, basically invalidated Star Trek canon for all future movies (and there will be future movies). Rebooting a franchise is one thing. Completely recreating it is quite another. Especially if it's as respected and well-loved as Star Trek. They've basically given themselves free reign to change everything in this alternative "Star Trek" universe they've created - if we can get away with Vulcan being destroyed in 2258, why not make the Borg a race of pot-smoking hippies seeking to assimilate everyone into their commune, or have the "alternative" Pickard be a cyborg from the future sent to save Wesley Crusher from another cyborg from the future? Hab SoSlI' Quch!, JJ, Hab SoSlI' Quch!!